10/29/26 - SHIUR 581

Drunk in Yerushalayim: Who’s Responsible for the Yeshiva Drinking Crisis?

How did lavish Simchas Beis HaShoeva celebrations turn into drinking parties with out-of-control buchurim – and who is responsible for what happens?
Are wealthy “gevirim” fueling a dangerous drinking culture in our community? Are they violating Lo Sa’amod al Dam Re’echa?
Why are some Roshei Yeshiva unwilling to confront the problem? Is “Boys will be boys” an acceptable response?
Why is alcohol such a serious problem among Orthodox teenagers and bochurim?

4 Comments

To the Editor:

In the same issue you ran a prominent ad for a Halacha Headlines episode (part 2) examining the yeshiva drinking crisis — out-of-control Simchas Beis HaShoeva parties, wealthy donors fueling a dangerous alcohol culture, and leadership unwilling to confront the problem.

On another page you ran a full two-page ad for a new frum housing community in Yerushalayim. Its central image shows men and boys seated at a table with a bottle of Macallan 12 placed front and center.

One ad presents ubiquitous alcohol as a communal problem requiring serious examination. The other presents it as a rabbinically endorsed, lifestyle-appropriate scene.

The juxtaposition is striking.

Yossi Wetstein

Baltimore, MD

C BERG

Thank you for bringing up the topic of drinking in Yeshivos. very powerful words by Rabbi Ginsburg as well as the other speakers.

My only problem with the disscusion was that you were placing a big blame on the Yeshivos.

Why can’t we call a spade a spade? Where does this issue come from? Every sucsessful wealthy person proves himself by his alcohol collection, every kiddush, every wedding, every parlor meeting, and it goes on and on. The only difference between bachurim and adults are that they have the ability to do it in private and the boys do it by other people but it has nothing to do with the yeshivos the blame is completely on the baal habatim and parents and maybe shul rabanim.

Most yeshivos don’t even have yeshiva over yom tov and many of the boys are all by themselves this is all something learned from back home and until this issue is fixed by its core which is every single event you wont be able to fix it. Its very easy to blame the kids, blame the yeshivos but lets be honest the real issue is the adults in society.

Thank you for bringing up this topic and i would love to hear what all the shul rabanim have to say about the kiddushim in their communities.

Shiur 365 Riddle

Load More...
loading...

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Rabbi Chaim Aryeh Zev Ginzberg, Eliezer, Rabbi Dovid Kaplan, Dr. Rivka Schwartz
Drunk in Yerushalayim: Who’s Responsible for the Yeshiva Drinking Crisis?
Downloads :
Rabbi Chaim Aryeh Zev Ginzberg, Eliezer, Rabbi Dovid Kaplan, Dr. Rivka Schwartz
Drunk in Yerushalayim: Who’s Responsible for the Yeshiva Drinking Crisis?
Downloads :
Contact